When Hope Keeps You Stuck

The Spark and The Cage

Hope is an interesting feeling. We’ve all felt it. We hope we have enough in our bank account as we walk up to pay at the counter, we hope the person texts us back, we hope we get the job, we hope a surgery goes well, we hope we find an apartment, we hope that the person we choose will choose us.

We hope. We hope. We hope.

Hope is a mixture of expectation, desire, and trust, a wager that what we want to happen will happen. And it’s worth noticing that we rarely choose it. Hope tends to arrive uninvited, the way hunger does. We don’t sit down one morning and decide to hope; we simply catch ourselves already hoping, already leaning toward a future that hasn’t come.

Hope is what helps many of us get out of bed, try “one more time,” believe that good things are in store for us. It’s the reason people rebuild after fires, apply after rejections, love after heartbreak. In this sense, hope isn’t naïve. It’s a kind of existential stubbornness, a refusal to let the present moment define what is possible. Dostoevsky wrote that “to live without hope is to cease to live,” and there’s something to that. A life stripped of hope doesn’t necessarily become more realistic, but it can become smaller, flatter, and directionless.

And yet, hope can be exhausting, if not detrimental. It can be harmful to hope for something that, according to all reason, patterns, and probability, won’t occur. There’s a version of hope that isn’t really hope at all; it’s avoidance mimicking hope. It lets us postpone the grief of admitting that something is over, that someone isn’t coming back, that a door has closed.

Hope can leave us stuck in the waiting room of our lives. And waiting rooms are strange places. We don’t decorate them, we don’t live in them, we just sit there, half-present, listening for our name to be called. Hope has a way of preventing us from accepting what is, or from noticing the alternatives that might align with us more. We keep the seat warm for a future that might have no intention of coming.

So maybe the question isn’t whether to hope. We will, we can’t help it. But let’s start asking ourselves what our hope is asking of us. Some hopes ask us to grow, to become the person who could receive the thing we’re hoping for. Other hopes trick us into becoming passive, stuck living in the “what if” rather than the “what is.”

Hope is the spark and the cage. It is a delicate and powerful incentive, and perhaps the most honest thing we can do is hold it the way we’d hold anything alive: gently, attentively, and with the willingness, when the time comes, to let it go.

---

In case you didn’t know, I’ve written a book: IT’S ON ME.

Review:

“My book of the year! Amazing book. My 2nd ordering because I wanted to give it as a gift.”